Demystifying Deception: Critical Thinking with the Strawman Fallacy 5-8th grade

On the hunt for an engaging lesson plan that hones critical thinking skills in your students? Your search concludes here! Help your students become critical thinkers, with depth and complexity, not just on April Fools' Day, but every day, developing a habit of careful consideration in how they approach information and decisions.

Our Straw Man Fallacy-inspired lesson plan offers an insightful addition to your existing curriculum, and can be used as a whole-class activity, for supply plans, in homeschooling, and gifted and extended programs. This lesson doesn't merely introduce the Straw man Fallacy; it invites students to dissect this deceptive technique through a captivating short story and empowers them to create a dialogue highlighting its use. Great for interpersonal conflict and more!

Key Components:

• Comprehensive lesson plan
• Clearly defined learning goals
• Four worksheets guiding students through the concept of the Straw man fallacy, scripting an argument using this technique, and reflecting on its significance.

This compact yet impactful lesson begins with students unraveling the enigma of the Straw man Fallacy—a deliberate misrepresentation of someone's opinion to facilitate its easy dismissal. The analytical journey unfolds as students delve into a concise story illustrating this fallacious tactic. Following this, they collaborate with a classmate to craft a short script portraying an argument where participants exploit the Straw man Fallacy. A set of suggested topics is provided for the teacher's convenience.

The crux of the lesson lies in students reflecting on the vital role of identifying the Straw man Fallacy in the realm of critical thinking and understanding why it's imperative to avoid its pitfalls.

Included in this package are four carefully designed worksheets, guiding students through the concept of the Straw man Fallacy, facilitating the creation of a dialogue utilizing this deceptive technique, and culminating in a reflective exploration of its importance.

The primary learning goals are to equip students with the ability to recognize and analyze the Straw man Fallacy, foster critical thinking skills, and instill an understanding of the significance of avoiding this deceptive tactic.

We believe that this lesson plan will not only enrich your teaching resources but will also empower your students to navigate arguments with acuity, recognize fallacious tactics, and contribute to a culture of thoughtful and informed dialogue.

Building Critical Thinkers is a resource designed to help educators in effectively teaching critical thinking skills to their students. While the importance of these skills has long been recognized, our education systems have not adequately focused on providing explicit training for educators in this regard.

Sign up here to get an amazing free full lesson on Confirmation Bias and the Full Moon! This store is just getting started, so check back soon for a bunch of new Critical Thinking Lessons for your students!

By purchasing this content, you have the right to use this in your own practice with your students. Please do not share with other educators in your schools or district, or post online. We hope you understand the reasons for this - we’d love to be able to continue to produce quality content in the future. All images found within are used with the appropriate rights. This material cannot be sold or distributed in any way that generates income. Some resources found on “Building Critical Thinkers” may be editable, and some may not be. Please respect that.

© 2023 Building Critical Thinkers. All Rights Reserved.